Review of the PDO Flipp case for iPhone 3G
After having the awesome DLO Folio leather case on my iPod Touch, I wanted something similar for the iPhone 3G I just got this week. Unfortunately, finding flip-style cases for the 3G isn't that easy yet since the products are all pretty new. I decided to take a gamble on the PDO Flipp and here's my quick review.
Yeah, yeah - I can hear you long-time readers pointing-out that I bashed all the hype on the original iPhone a year ago, but now I bought one (albeit the 3G update)? Yep, I did and so far I love it. But this isn't a review about the iPhone 3G.
It seems that many of the iPhone cases are a design that leaves the screen wide-open, for example, those rubber backing type cases that go for about $15-30. That's great for the back of the phone, but if I'm throwing it into my pocket which may have some coins or other items in it, I'd prefer a bit of protection for the screen as well.
The other most common type of case covers the back and screen, but these usually use an ugly plastic window that, well, frankly looks like crap when it get partially stuck to the screen. One of the primary great things about the iPhone is the nice, bright, high-res screen, after all.
So, I was on a mission to find a decent "folio-style" case. The DLO HipCase Folio is what I've been using on my iPod Touch since I bought it and it's an awesome case. It's sturdy, fits well, protects the precious Touch inside, and looks good to boot. If you have an iPod Touch, I highly recommend this case.
The iPhone is a bit thicker than the Touch, though, so it can't use the same case. Oh, I tried, but it's just about 1/8" too thick to comfortably slide into that DLO case.
Searching for iPod cases that have the flipping screen cover and magnetic "latch" wasn't too easy. There just aren't that many of them out there to choose from yet. A friend at work sent me the link to the PDO Flipp iPhone 3G case and since they were running a special for free shipping and I found a coupon code for 10% off, I decided to try it out.
Construction:
The Flipp is made from a nice, soft leather much like the DLO case. It's slightly padded and feels good in your hand. It has a subtle leather "texture" on it, which looks nice unlike one of the other cases (which is sold in the Apple Stores) that has a hideous shiny alligator-skin pattern embossed on it - yuck! The interior is lined with a black velour type "fuzz" which will not scratch the iPhone. The edges and seams are stitched nicely and don't have any hanging threads or any other visible quality issues.
It features a belt clip that is strong and appears to be well attached. The clip rotates, so you can orient your phone to point whatever direction you prefer. The cover is held-shut by two strong embedded magnets, one on each side of the iPhone's button.
Various cut-outs on the Flipp case allow you to connect to the headphone jack, dock connector, push the volume buttons on the side, and let the speakers in the iPhone play.
Fit:
Unlike some cases which I've read reviews of where the iPhone sits loosely inside, the Flipp's fit on the phone is slightly snug. That will keep it from accidentally sliding-out, which is something my old DLO case wasn't perfect at.
The cut-outs for the speakers and dock connector align well. The volume button cut-outs are just barely large enough. Actually, even with my phone pressed all the way down into the case, the top 1/16" or so of the volume "up" is covered with the thin leather. This doesn't appear that it will be a problem, but it may have been better for PDO to make one single cut-out for the volume and ringer-mute switch than to try to make them separate.
The camera cut-out is one thing that doesn't align very well. Because the case is leather and there are slight variances in the shape/etc., my iPhone sits just a tad off-center which places the camera lens out of alignment with the matching hole in the case. It's a simple matter to push the iPhone over slightly when you take a photo, but for those who snap lots of photos using their phone, it might be annoying. More on this below.
The magnets that hold the flip shut are strong and I don't anticipate any issues with unexpected openings. Closing the flap gives a satisfying muted "snap" as the magnets pull it shut.
Use:
I like that I can connect the dock connector without removing the iPhone from the case. The headphone jack is readily accessible and other than the minor issues I described above regarding the alignment of the volume and camera holes, the case is quite nice. It definitely makes the iPhone 3G chunkier, but you have to expect that when you're enclosing it in padded leather.
The flap/folio design is great in my opinion because it provides protection for the screen, but it moves completely out of the way when you want to see and touch that big, beautiful screen. It's the best of both worlds for me. Someone who takes pics with the built-in camera, though may not like the folio design as the flap folds over and will cover the lens unless you hold it up with your hand. For me, I'll probably just pull the iPhone out of the case when I need to take a photo, but if you're like a teenage girl who takes photos of everything every minute of the day, the folio design won't be for you.
Because of the added thickness when the iPhone is in the case, you very likely won't be able to put it into any kind of dock without removing the phone. I have a set of Logitech speakers which I don't have a dock adapter in, hence making the opening very large, but with the belt clip, I still can't put the iPhone into the speakers while it's in the PDO Flipp case. Adding any kind of case will probably affect many docks, so that's just common sense, but I figured it was worth noting anyway.
Conclusion:
The PDO Flipp is a nice folio-style case for the iPhone 3G. It is well constructed and will offer good protection for the iPhone without looking silly like some of those bright pink rubber cases. The screen is easily accessible and you can actually touch the screen, which I think is better than the cases with a permanent plastic window. The Flipp comes with a free screen protector also, which is a nice bonus, although I haven't tried it yet and I'm not sure that I will need it.
The Good:
- Quality construction and materials.
- Access to all buttons and ports on the iPhone 3G.
- Rotating, strong belt-clip.
- Competitive price (other similar cases are $10 more).
- Snug fit keeps the iPhone in place.
The Bad:
- Makes your iPhone 3G a bit thicker.
- Camera cut-out may be an issue.
- Volume button cut-out is too tight.
Overall, I think this case is a good purchase for someone wanting a nice leather folio-type case for the iPhone 3G. It's well-made, nice to look at, and very reasonably priced at $30 in a field of extremely over-priced iPhone 3G accessories. I'm personally happy with it and think it's one of the better options for this style of case at this time.
Amazon is offering the PDO Flipp case for $24 right now, which is an even better deal than I got. And, here is the manufacturer's page for the PDO Flipp iPhone 3G case.
Here are some photos I took. Sorry for the "1 per line" format - I don't know how to get this stupid Wordpress caption thing to not do that (if you know, please leave a comment!)
PDO Flipp case for iPhone 3G box front
PDO Flipp case for iPhone 3G box backside
Flipp case for iPhone 3G box side
Flipp case box bottom
Flipp case next to my iPhone 3G
Flipp case opened with the cardboard iPhone inside
Back of the opened Flipp case
iPhone 3G inside the Flipp case
Side view of the iPhone in the case
Top view of the opened case
Top view of the opened case
Bottom view showing the dock and speaker cut-outs
Side view showing the volume and mute switch cut-outs
Showing the camera cut-out slightly out of alignment
Related Stuff:
Time to clean the fridge - working in an all male officeWhen you're in an office filled with computer nerd guys, the refrigerator is bound to grow a moldy nugget or two here and there. What do you do when you find an especially furry food nugget? I often make what I call the "Two buck challenge" to people. Such a challenge is often centered around eating something especially disgusting in return for a trivial amount of my money. Yeah, I'm basically looking for someone to voluntarily become a tool for a laughable amount of cash. However, most of my challenges are actually doable. For example, I might offer...
Add a retro interface to your high-tech music collection
Sometimes, the older way of doing things is easier for people to use. What happens when you have thousands of songs digitally encoded in iTunes or some other player? It makes for great random/shuffle playing, where you can let songs play for hours on end, and it works OK when you're sitting at the computer. However, how do you control the playback of such a collection in a relatively drunk-proof manner while you're holding a party, for example. Well, you could add a cartridge-based juke-box style control system. Using a PIC16F672 embedded in empty CD jewel cases, a group of friends...
ARGH! Enough about the iPhone already!!!
[Vent mode on] For the past week, nearly every single one of my RSS feeds has been 'disabled' as far as I'm concerned. It doesn't matter if it was Engadget, Gizmodo, or electronics hacking sites, they were all worthless for the week and continue to be so today. Why? Because all they are talking about is the frickin' iPhone!!!! Everywhere! Every nook and cranny - every website large or small... iPhone, iPhone, iPhone! Stupid photos of people waiting in line to buy them -- and not just in one place! People standing in line have been photographed from...
Amazing robot with perfect balance
Able to balance perfectly on only two wheels, you have to see the videos to appreciate just how cool this is! I had been seeing a few posts for this "Murata Boy" bicycle riding robot on some of the tech sites I frequent. I looked at the photos and thought that it might be neat, but ultimately, I was envisioning the old Evil Kineval gyroscopic motorcycle toy I had as a child and figured it was nothing worth looking into. Then, I found some videos of it and was able to appreciate the precision and control which this robot...
Disney World monorail pusher photos
Here are a few pics of the gas-powered emergency monorail car at Disney World I took in 2004. I was in Disney World in June of 2004 when I took these. There was a pretty bad storm coming-over (not a hurricane, fortunately!) and lightning had apparently hit a portion of the monorail track which caused something to blow and shut-down all of the trains. We were at the front of the line to head home when this happened and therefore, had a very good view of the little pusher car (I guess that's what you'd call it) that is used in...
Explore more
Previous post: Tip: Leopard Mail.app won’t quit with IMAP
Next post: Simple DIY microcontroller based video game console
August 9th, 2008 at 7:02 pm
[...] pundapun wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptThis doesn’t appear that it will be a problem, but it may have been better for PDO to make one single cut-out for the volume and ringer-mute switch than to try to make them separate. The camera cut-out is one thing that doesn’t align … [...]
August 9th, 2008 at 9:07 pm
[...] Alex Brooks wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptThe interior is lined with a black velour type “fuzz” which will not scratch the iPhone. The edges and seams are stitched nicely and don’t have any hanging threads or any other visible quality issues. It features a belt clip that is … [...]
August 9th, 2008 at 9:08 pm
[...] webmaster wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptYeah, yeah - I can you long-time reading pointing-out that I bashed all the hype on the original iPhone a year ago, but now I bought one (albeit the 3G update)? Yep, I did and so far I love it. But this isn’t a review about the iPhone … [...]
August 9th, 2008 at 9:14 pm
[...] what a joke wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptIt’s well-made, nice to look at, and very reasonably priced at $30 in a field of extremely over-priced iPhone 3G accessories. I’m personally happy with it and think it’s one of the better options for this style of case at this time. … [...]
August 20th, 2008 at 7:03 pm
Your review for the PDO Flipp case is great - thank you!. I am
surprised how little info there is on the company’s website for the
case. The rotating clip is what I am looking for, which I did not know
that this case had until I read your review.
I am wondering - how easy is it to pull the phone out of the case when
it is on your belt (rather than pulling the whole thing, case and all
off of your belt)? Is it the fit so snug that you are better off always
leaving it in the case?
Lastly, did you consider the Marware Flip Vue? That’s the other case
that I’m looking at, but I’m leaning towards the PDO’s smooth exterior.
Thanks
-Jim
August 20th, 2008 at 7:05 pm
Hi Jim,
Thanks for the nice comments on the review - I’m glad someone out there is reading it after
I took the time to write it ;^)
The clip rotates on a single rivet type attachment. It’s not a ratcheting pivot or anything
fancy like that.
It is a “good fit”. I take mine in and out of the case at least once per day as I don’t use
the case when I go to work, but I do use it when I exercise and bum around the house.
As an example, if you were to turn the case upside down, the iPhone would slide out
slowly. A bit of pushing with your finger and it removes easily. I even have a screen
protector on my phone and the case isn’t so tight that it peels it up or interferes in any
way.
I looked at several and there seem to be more coming out every day. As usual, I’m
just a bit early to the party ;^) I’m still quite pleased with the PDO Flipp and don’t
wish I had bought something else, so I guess that’s a pretty good endorsement.
Hope that helps,
Mike